Lumbar disc herniation: when is surgery necessary? Frequently asked questions

This is one of the questions I am asked most frequently during consultations. Here I answer, briefly, the most common questions about when a lumbar disc herniation needs surgery and when it does not.

Short answer: Most lumbar disc herniations improve without surgery within weeks or a few months. Surgery is considered when leg pain does not improve over time, when there is loss of strength, or when the pain prevents normal life activities. It is urgent if there are problems urinating or controlling bowel movements, or numbness in the genital area.

Dr. Francisco Arteaga with the endoscope in the operating theatre

Are all lumbar disc hernias operated on?

No. Many people have a hernia on the MRI and do not need surgery. Hernia surgery is performed when the patient’s symptoms do not improve or worsen. During the consultation, I review the MRI, explain it to the patient, and clearly tell him whether or not he needs surgery.

When is it urgent to operate on a herniated disc?

When problems occur with urinating or controlling bowel movements, numbness in the genital area or between the legs, or rapid loss of strength in one leg (for example, the leg that «falls off» when walking), you must go to the Emergency Department on the same day, without waiting for an appointment.

How long can you wait before considering surgery?

It depends on each case. As a guideline, if after about 6 to 12 weeks the pain in the leg continues to limit your life, it is advisable for a spine specialist to assess whether surgery might help you. If there is loss of strength, you should not wait that long.

What evidence do I need to know if I need to have surgery?

Normally, a magnetic resonance of the lumbar spine. The test alone does not decide: you need to check during the examination that the hernia is the cause of your symptoms. If you already have a magnetic resonance and reports, bring them to the consultation.

What technique do I use to operate a herniated disc?

Whenever the case allows, I use endoscopic spine surgery or minimally invasive techniques. It is performed through a small incision, which usually means less pain after the operation and a faster recovery.

Can the hernia reappear after surgery?

Yes, it can happen in some patients, because the disc remains the same. That is why, after the surgery, I explain to them how to care for their back and how to gradually return to their activity.

More information: Lumbar Disc Herniation.

Do you want me to evaluate your case? I accept private consultations at Calle Juan Sebastián Elcano 26, Seville, from Monday to Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. The first consultation costs 150 €. Request an appointment via WhatsApp at +34 614 708 664 or Tell me your case with the online assessment.